Investigation and inquest
On 19th October 2017 I commenced an investigation into the death of Andrew Reid. The investigation concluded on the 5th April 2018 and the conclusion was one of suicide. The medical cause of death was hanging.
Circumstances of the death
On 17th October 2017 Andrew Reid was found suspended from a ligature at Longford Park, Edge Lane, Stretford.
Coroner’s concerns
1. The inquest heard that when Mr Reid went to see his GP she was very concerned about the risk he posed to himself and wanted him to be seen urgently by the Home Based Treatment Team (HBTT). The initial call was to the Manchester team -because the GP practice was within the City Of Manchester-who accept referrals from GPs. The Manchester HBTT are commissioned to provide a 24/7 Urgent Assessment Team that GPs can refer into. However, as Mr Reid was a Trafford resident the referral was not accepted and the GP called the Trafford HBTT. Under the terms of their commissioned service they cannot accept referrals from GPs and contact is via the RAID team in A and E. In this case that meant Mr Reid was told he would have to go to A and E. The inquest was told that the differences in level of provision for those with mental health are based on the decisions made by each commissioning authority. As a result residents of GM with mental health issues have a different level of support and route to access services.
2. In Trafford the outcome of the commissioning is that there are no emergency GP referrals dealt with OOH. They can only be dealt with Monday to Friday by the CMHT. GPs outside these times dealing with emergency mental health issues for Trafford residents have to ask patients to make their way to A and E for assessment. If they are concerned that a patient may not make it to A and E then they have to ask the Police to check with A and E -as happened in the case of Mr Reid