Investigation and inquest
On 3/6/21 an investigation was opened into the death of Gwynne SAMUEL
The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on: 16/6/22
The conclusion of the inquest was recorded as:
Death by Accident .
The medical cause of death was:
1a) Chest infection
1b) Hip fracture (operated) and long lie
2 Chronic kidney disease , Frailty of old age, Ischaemic Heart Disease
Circumstances of the death
Gwynne Samuel (GS) was a 95-year-old gentleman who lived alone. On 10/5/2021 he suffered a fall at home. GS was experiencing pain, a swollen neck and was bleeding. His daughter discovered him and called for an ambulance at 19:53 on 10/5/21. An ambulance eventually arrived at 07:36 on 11/5/21.
GS was admitted to the Grange University Hospital, Llanfrecha, where he was diagnosed with a fractured neck of femur. GS was in a poor condition and the evidence heard at the inquest confirmed that he had suffered an acute kidney injury caused by rhabdomyolysis. Rhabdomyolysis is directly attributable to the long lie GS had experienced whilst waiting for an emergency ambulance.
As a result, the necessary operation on his hip was delayed until 13/5/21, by which time he was developing a chest infection.
Post-operatively GS went into a further decline and was overwhelmed by pneumonia. He died on 20/5/21.
Coroner’s concerns
GS was an elderly gentleman who had suffered a significant fall. The time it took for an ambulance to arrive and convey him to hospital contributed to his death insofar that the development of an acute kidney injury, which compromised his treatment and general condition, was caused by a long lie.
A report obtained from WAST indicated that GS had been categorised as an Amber 2, which I understand is an urgent clinical priority considered serious but not life threatening.
Whilst I accept that there was no evidence that GS was in immediate peril, it would appear that the clinical ramifications of an elderly person lying for a long period of time are not taken into account during the categorisation process.
Whilst I heard evidence, and understand, the pressures on the ambulance service during the pandemic and the inability to release emergency ambulances due to congestion in hospital emergency departments, the inability to provide an ambulance to a patient determined to be in a serious condition (Amber 2) for 12 hours, puts lives in danger and, as in this case, may contribute to their death.