Investigation and inquest
On 23rd April 2018 I commenced an investigation into the death of Savannah-Rose Michelle Owen. The investigation concluded on 7th November 2018 and the conclusion was one of Natural Causes.
The medical cause of death was 1a) Unascertained
Circumstances of the death
Savannah-Rose Michelle Owen was a healthy baby born on 16th February 2018. On 22nd April 2018 she fell asleep on a nursing pillow on the sofa at her home address. Her parents realised she had become unresponsive and an ambulance was called. Attempts to resuscitate her were unsuccessful. A post-mortem did not find a cause of death but did exclude any third party involvement or suspicious circumstances and on the balance of probabilities would have been due to natural causes.
Coroner’s concerns
The inquest heard that:
Savannah-Rose’s mother had purchased the multi-purpose nursing pillow from a well-known supermarket chain. There were warnings about its use on a card that came with the pillow but was not attached to it. On the warning/information leaflet were 5 pictures of a baby positioned on the pillow. In only 2 images was the baby with an adult. On the other 3 the baby was alone.
The inquest heard that sleeping unsupervised on such pillows was not consistent with the safe sleeping advice given to new parents. However:
1. Unlike many items associated with babies/young children such as high chairs/cots there was no specific safety regulation for such items. Instead manufacturers had to interpret the all-embracing safety policy. This risked inconsistent safety warnings/labelling;
2. It was unclear if Health Visitors/ Midwives in the community seeing multi-use pillows being used were flagging up the risks of allowing babies to be propped on them for naps and that their use in such a way was wholly inconsistent with safe sleeping advice;
3. On the warning/information leaflet were 5 pictures of a baby positioned on the pillow. In only 2 images was the baby with an adult. On the other 3 the baby was alone. The inquest was told that this could be misleading as to the importance of never leaving a baby unattended on the pillow; and
4. The warning label was not attached to the item therefore; once the package had been opened, there was a high risk that the warning label would be lost. On resale/recycling of baby items this meant that second hand users/purchasers were unlikely to see the warning.