Investigation and inquest
On 23/04/20 I commenced an investigation into the death of Leslie Clewarth aged 86. The investigation concluded at the end of the Inquest on 06/11/20.
The Inquest reached a narrative conclusion to the effect that Leslie Clewarth died in hospital from natural causes: 1a. aspiration pneumonia, 1b. small bowel obstruction 1c. adhesions within the peritoneal cavity and II. ischaemic heart disease.
Circumstances of the death
The family of Mr Clewarth were called before 7am on 07/04/20 due to the deterioration in his condition. They were permitted to remain at his bedside throughout the day, notwithstanding the COVID19 visiting restrictions then in force.
Concerns were raised by his daughter and her husband in relation to:
(1) The NG tube previously inserted was no longer in place.
(2) The syringe driver was empty at some point after 4pm that day. In consequence, he was deprived of essential medication and hence died in agony after choking on faecal material aspirated.
(3) After he had died an injection of Buscopan was made.
(4) He had not been treated for a severe coronary condition despite being in hospital for many weeks.
Medical records which should have documented these matters were missing or inadequate.
Coroner’s concerns
(1) Without adequate records showing the care provided or dosage administered, it was not possible to corroborate the testimony of nurses who had attended to Mr Clewarth on the afternoon he died. This fuelled the suspicions raised by his daughter and her husband.
(2) Drugs which were left unused after Mr Clewarth’s death were not accounted for.
Without proper records there is a risk that essential care may not be provided or is erroneously duplicated, thus potentially putting a patient's safety or health at risk.