Investigation and inquest
On 30/11/2017 I commenced an investigation into the death of Tyla Katherine Joan COOK aged 16. The investigation concluded at the end of an inquest on 16/09/2019. The medical cause of death was:
1a Systemic inflammatory response of unknown cause
1b
1c
II Paracetamol Overdose
The conclusion of the inquest was: Natural causes contributed to by paracetamol overdose
Circumstances of the death
Tyla Cook had a complex mental health history, including autism, and was under care of NSFT in the community. There was no up to date written Care or Crisis Plan in place. Due to his becoming less engaged and more distressed he was seen on 7 November 2017 and 8 November 2017. On 9 November 2017 at approximately 12.45 Tyla said he had taken 24 paracetamol tablets and refused to go to hospital. It was recognised there was an 8 hour treatment window within which an antidote was to be given to best effect. An ambulance arrived at 13:50. Tyla was discussed, assessed and deemed not to have mental capacity and was carried to the ambulance which left at 15:03. He became increasingly distressed during the journey. On arrival at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital at 15:14 there was discussion as to the best way to get Tyla into the hospital. He was given a sedative which had little if any effect. In the event, Tyla was removed into the hospital. He was then sedated and an antidote delivered at 18:00. Tyla received treatment and his condition was monitored. On showing signs of an infection he was treated with antibiotic s. Against expectation Tyla’s condition deteriorated and on 15 November 2017 at Queen Elizabeth Hospital Tyla suffered a cardiac arrest and died.
Coroner’s concerns
Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust
1. It was agreed at the CETR meeting on 9 August 2017 that Tyla was to be seen by the Eating Disorder Service. He was not seen until 25 October 2017. The evidence was the 11 week delay in seeing Tyla was due to a heavy caseload and the practitioner having to remove other cases from his caseload before he was able to work with Tyla;
2. There was no written up-to-date care and crisis plans in place. The most recent written care plan related to Tyla being an inpatient at the Dragonfly Unit, from where he was discharged on 9 August 2017. The written plans were therefore several months out of date. This is against Trust Policy. Evidence was heard that at a CETR meeting on 6 November 2017 a period of a further 3 months was requested to prepare an up to date written care plan. In the event, and despite the family’s repeated requests for plans in writing, it was decided the care plan could be commenced by 30 November 2017, on the basis Tyla’s input into the Care Plan was important and it would take time to gain his meaningful input. The evidence was that there were oral plans in place which were relayed to the parents (including at times of distress), who continued to request plans in writing. The high level of distress and anxiety within Tyla’s home was recognised. An interim written plan was not considered nor that a written plan may have helped the family in providing support to Tyla. Steps have been taken by the Trust to recognise when up to date written plans are not in place and it is understood staff have undergone some work in improving the quality of care plans. However in this case an active decision was made not to update the written plan for some time. Further the evidence did not reveal any insight into the support a written plan could have given the family to support Tyla.
West Norfolk Clinical Commissioning Group, Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust, Queen Elizabeth Hospital and Norfolk County Council
3. The Review carried out by the West Norfolk Clinical Commissioning Group in May 2019 recommended a multi-disciplinary learning event involving participants from Norfolk and Suffolk Foundation Trust, Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Norfolk County Council and East of England Ambulance Service Trust be developed and implemented to train staff on how to apply good non-technical skills (teamwork, leadership, task prioritisation and communication) when responding to an emergency. At the inquest it became clear no steps have been taken to organise this event and there is confusion as to who is responsible for arranging this learning event. The Care providers indicated it was the West Norfolk Clinical Commissioning Group. The West Norfolk Clinical Commissioning Group do not appear to accept responsibility for organisation of the event. Tyla died on 15 November 2017. The West Norfolk Clinical Commissioning Group Review was published 8 May 2019. No steps have been taken with regard to this learning event, save East of England Ambulance Service Trust has been in contact with the West Norfolk Clinical Commissioning Group. There is concern that a multi-disciplinary learning event will not be organised and will not take place.