Investigation and inquest
On 9th November 2018 I commenced an investigation into the death of Ioannis AVGOUSTI. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 18th April 2019.The conclusion of the inquest was NARRATIVE CONCLUSION – Please see attached sheet.
Circumstances of the death
See Record of Inquest
Coroner’s concerns
(1) On the 2nd September 2017 the NICE Guidance for the Diagnosis and Management of Allergy was not followed.
It was suggested to me that following the episode of anaphylaxis on the 27th July 2018 the NICE protocol was followed and therefore lessons had been learned to protect future patients however, I found that that was not the case.
Whilst two Mast Cell Tryptase tests had been carried out and there had been some rather sporadic marking of a possibility of allergy in some of the hospital documentation, there had been no proper communication either immediately following the incident or later on within the hospital itself nor to the GP nor to Mr. Avgousti himself or his family. This was simply not good enough.
(2) On the 6th October 2018 although the hospital had noted that he was allergic to Co-Amoxiclav and although the paper medication notes noted that fact he was written up for that medication and it was administered to him.
I saw evidence of a poorly documented, from the point of view of time, NEWS observation. Although at the top of the chart there were the numbers 2 0 (20) I found on the balance of probabilities that set of observations had more likely been taken at about 20:10 or 20:15 hours.
The observations were added up to 9. In fact the total was 13.
NEWS is a tool to ensure that the deteriorating patient is recognised and given help and escalated, if appropriate, to Intensive Care.
This set of observations was not acted on in accordance with the directions and no escalation was made. There should have been a MET call then i.e., at around 20:15 hours to a specialist registrar (there was one on duty)
If this call had been made and if the appropriate doctor had been called to see Mr. Avgousti it is possible that although the sepsis protocol would I believe have been implemented, it would have been realised that he had an allergy to Co-Amoxiclav and he would have been given an appropriate alternative.
Whilst I cannot say categorically that this would have been the case I believe it is highly likely.
NEWS is an important tool and should not be ignored as it was on Vallance Ward on the night of the 6th October 2018.
(3) On the same night the nurses and the doctors were working 12½ hour “weekend” shifts”. The day nursing shift was one nurse short and so far as the doctors were concerned they were, as I understand they always are at weekends, too few in number and as a result all staff in hospital are thoroughly stretched and stressed and under resourced.
This is no way to run a hospital service.
Exacerbating factors in Mr. Avgousti’s case were that his rapid deterioration took place at around handover for both doctors and nurses, thus adding even more pressure to the situation.